LET'S FIGHT BACK

LET'S FIGHT BACK
GOD BLESS AMERICA

Monday, November 16, 2026

Kafka Survives in our Universities

Kafka Survives in our Universities (Previously published)

ShareShare
TweetTweet
ForwardForward

A modern university is an institution of higher learning and research with a long standing idea that the university is the model of academic freedom, and more broadly of freedom of speech. The first documentary evidence of this tradition is traced to the University of Bologna which, circa 1155, adopted an academic charter which guaranteed the right of a traveling scholar to unhindered passage in the interest of education. The concept of academic freedom is, in our times, recognized internationally by the 1988 successor to the Bologna charter, the Magna Charta Universitatum which has been signed by 805 universities from 85 countries. 

One of the criticisms made of the modern University is that, the adoption of business management models has eclipsed pedagogical or intellectual concerns, resulting in “corporate universities.” This may be an exaggeration, but it is clear that, with corporate management techniques influencing the university administrative environment, a top-down, business management attitude follows. This intolerant command and control management mindset is perfectly suitable for the business world, but it conflicts, in a university setting, with the nurturing of academic freedom. 

It is not a case of universities leaders engaging in open censorship or infringements of freedom of speech. It is a much more subtle creation of an intimidating Kafkaesque (Franz Kafka 1883-1924) milieu for faculty members. That is to say, the imposition of a management style that foments the powerlessness of the individual with bizarre, dictates of authority, where the individual faculty member feels powerless to influence what is happening. 

In our South Florida community, two recent situations involving the University of Miami and Florida International University serve to illustrate the Kafkaesque administrative environment in place. 

In July 2017, Dr. Jaime Suchlicki, then Director of the Institute for Cuban and Cuban-American Studies (ICCAS) at the University of Miami, wrote to his staff: 

“This is to inform you that as of August 15, 2017, I will be leaving the University of Miami. I have been instructed by the Office of the Provost to effect the cessation of operations for the Institute for Cuban and Cuban-American Studies, consequently your position has been eliminated and you will be placed on layoff status as of August 15, 2017.” 

The Institute for Cuban and Cuban-American Studies had been for many years a very critical and high- profile voice against the Castro regime in Cuba, and the community reacted forcefully protesting its closing. In the outcry that followed, University President Dr. Julio Frenk disingenuously stated that it had not been his intention to close ICCAS, and committed, at a meeting with community leaders on August 18, 2017, to hire a new Director and resume operations. As of this writing, a year later, ICCAS has never resumed operations and its anti-Castro voice was effectively silenced with a chilling Kafkaesque message. 

An analogous Kafkaesque situation is taking place at Florida International University (FIU). Dr. Modesto (Mitch) Maidique, who was FUI’s distinguished president for 14 years (1986-2000), and is now an FIU professor, has fallen out of favor with the University’s leadership. Dr. Maidique’s accomplishments as FIU’s President are unprecedented and unquestionable. So much so, that in 2009 the Board of Trustees renamed the University’s main campus as the Modesto Maidique Campus (MMC) to honor him. 

It appears that FIU’s Board of Trustees is now unhappy that Dr. Maidique has criticized their leadership and, in retaliation, some members are proposing to remove Maidique’s name from the campus, purportedly to be able to rename the campus after a prospective donor. As with the ICCAS case, motives are certainly suspect. 

In the interest of full disclosure, as it relates to these examples, I must note that I was a member of the ICCAS team when the UM’s President ordered its dismantlement, and I consider Mitch Maidique a friend. But, I view both of these instances as Kafkaesque specimens where administrative power is used to silence dissent. Most troubling, however, is that this intolerance originates with university leaders that should be teaching our youth, in the classroom and with their personal example, the democratic values that enrich our society: pluralism and freedom of expression.